Fridays with Rogers Partners
At our weekly meeting, Jack Haddad discussed the recent decision of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice in Raycraft v. 2208261 Ontario Inc., 2026 ONSC 6125. In this case, a plaintiff who had consumed cannabis went to a restaurant and had proceeded to drink about five to six beers. The plaintiff went to the washroom upstairs, and was followed upstairs by an unhoused individual. The individual did not enter the washroom with the plaintiff or interact with her.
The plaintiff complained to the manager, and became upset with the manager. The plaintiff was asked to leave the restaurant, and she wandered around a bit downtown. The plaintiff later came back and tried to order more drinks, while also demanding fellow patrons call the police. The manager asked her to leave at this second visit, and after she refused the manager physically escorted the plaintiff out of the restaurant by the shoulders and held the door shut. The plaintiff proceeded to bang her hands against the door. The plaintiff suffered a fracture in her right hand and alleged that she was injured by the manager as her hand “made contact with the door” when leaving. The plaintiff commenced an action for assault and battery.
Holding
The Trial Judge, Justice I.R. Smith, found no liability for the defendants, and proceeded to dismiss the claim.
Analysis
Justice Smith found there was no question that the facts suggest a battery (a non-trivial intentional touching) had occurred. However, the defendant pleaded that the manager had the right to remove the plaintiff under section 34 of the Liquor License Act. Under this section, a license holder must ensure that a person who unlawfully attends an establishment does not remain on the premises, and may request that person to leave the premises immediately. If the person does not leave, they may be forcibly removed by using no more force than is necessary.
In this case, the plaintiff was at the restaurant in violation of the Liquor License Act for re-attending an establishment on a day she had been asked to leave. The manager had lawful authority to ask the plaintiff to leave the restaurant on her second visit, and when she failed to do so he had lawful authority to physically escort her out of the restaurant. Based on the testimony at trial, Justice Smith found that there was a reasonable use of force as the manager gently guided her by the upper arms out of the restaurant, and the plaintiff could not explain how her hand “came into contact with the door” in this process.
Justice Smith therefore held that the manager’s lawful authority and conduct in removing the plaintiff served as a complete defence to the tort claim. In the alternate, Justice Smith found no causation for the injury to the hand, and alluded to the fact the plaintiff proceeded to bang on the door for several minutes as being the likely cause of the plaintiff’s injuries.